ILLUSTRATED ENCYCLOPEDIA OF MILITARY UNIFORMS OF THE 19TH CENTURY
5 posters
Page 1 of 1
ILLUSTRATED ENCYCLOPEDIA OF MILITARY UNIFORMS OF THE 19TH CENTURY
Lorenz Publishing can really pump out these uniform books, and they aren't expensive. Amazon.com has some reviews of this particular one on "19th century uniforms" that describe the product well, with pros and cons. Nice pictures, tons of disjointed information with a number of errors. Gratuitous verbiage with nothing to do with the subject (did you know that after the British left India, it became two countries, one Hindu and one Muslim?). It's not really about the 19th century, just those wars that are well covered by the Company of Military Historians and Osprey books, except for the addition of a small part on the Italian unification wars. Non-uniforms have a surprisingly strong appearance, with coverage of American Indians, Zulus, and Boer citizens (well, one of those is in a uniform).
This book is a good successor to the regular appearances of broad-coverage uniform books for beginners that have been published for the last 30 years. It is a good successor because the authors do take advantage of the specialist research from all that time (none of which is credited).
This book is a good successor to the regular appearances of broad-coverage uniform books for beginners that have been published for the last 30 years. It is a good successor because the authors do take advantage of the specialist research from all that time (none of which is credited).
mconrad- Posts : 386
Join date : 2008-07-27
Re: ILLUSTRATED ENCYCLOPEDIA OF MILITARY UNIFORMS OF THE 19TH CENTURY
I wouldn't rush out to buy it though, very American centric. I have a copy if anyone wants to buy it from me.
Sean- Posts : 1129
Join date : 2008-04-03
Re: ILLUSTRATED ENCYCLOPEDIA OF MILITARY UNIFORMS OF THE 19TH CENTURY
Yeah it is very American Civil War centered, I would say that at least 40% of the book is American Civil War related. I was quite disappointed
They have companion books on the Uniforms of the American War of Independence, the Uniforms of the Napoleonic Wars, and an upcoming book on the uniforms of World War One which is due this August.
They have companion books on the Uniforms of the American War of Independence, the Uniforms of the Napoleonic Wars, and an upcoming book on the uniforms of World War One which is due this August.
ChrisF202- Posts : 338
Join date : 2008-05-19
Location : Long Island, New York, USA
Re: ILLUSTRATED ENCYCLOPEDIA OF MILITARY UNIFORMS OF THE 19TH CENTURY
Dear,
Can anyone give me the download link of this book?
Regards
Shams
Can anyone give me the download link of this book?
Regards
Shams
sbintayab- Posts : 137
Join date : 2010-12-29
Age : 40
Location : Clayton, Victoria, Australia
Compare "expert encyclopedia" to real experts
Here's a color painting created for Military Uniforms of the 19th Century, which is adverted as an "expert guide," "scrupulously researched," and "immaculately detailed." Then compare it to the real thing as presented in Don Troiani's Soldiers in America (Troiani, Coates, and Kochan). Some of the errors: added vertical strip of braid down the front opening, totally wrong collar ornamentation, missed the inverted bell-shape outline of the several rows of chest braid, buttons look flat instead of ball, which braid crosses over which in the design is wrong, bottom front is pointed instead of horizontally flat.
mconrad- Posts : 386
Join date : 2008-07-27
Compare "expert encyclopedia" to real experts
Could this be an attempt at illustrating the 3rd New Jersey cavalry?
Collar would still have had the buttons and braid but this could vary as I believe the uniform was purchased by the state and possibly prone to alterations due to funding, also a number of individuals tailored their uniform to taste.
None of which explains the fact that if there had been extensive research any abnormality should have had an explanation to the reason why.
See the example of the 3rd New Jersey's uniform on page 72 of Katcher's 'The American Soldier', quite similar to this uniform.
Regards
WF
Collar would still have had the buttons and braid but this could vary as I believe the uniform was purchased by the state and possibly prone to alterations due to funding, also a number of individuals tailored their uniform to taste.
None of which explains the fact that if there had been extensive research any abnormality should have had an explanation to the reason why.
See the example of the 3rd New Jersey's uniform on page 72 of Katcher's 'The American Soldier', quite similar to this uniform.
Regards
WF
wfrad- Posts : 16308
Join date : 2008-04-16
Location : Durham UK
Re: ILLUSTRATED ENCYCLOPEDIA OF MILITARY UNIFORMS OF THE 19TH CENTURY
The ultimate mistake in this book is labeling a British Indian Army lancer as a US Army infantry officer ca. 1898! Hopefully the upcoming World War One book will be error free ...
ChrisF202- Posts : 338
Join date : 2008-05-19
Location : Long Island, New York, USA
Similar topics
» Mexican uniforms 19th century
» German & French 19th Century
» Military Uniforms of Haiti in the XIX Century
» Nepalese Uniforms of the late XIX Century/early XX Century
» Venezuela 19th Century
» German & French 19th Century
» Military Uniforms of Haiti in the XIX Century
» Nepalese Uniforms of the late XIX Century/early XX Century
» Venezuela 19th Century
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum